by Marty Dodson
Sep 16, 2016
Over and over, during my songwriting career, I have been a part of debates over the issue of holding on to publishing vs signing away publishing. As a general rule, keeping your publishing would be preferable. After all, the publishing share is 1/2 of your share of the song. So, why would anyone sign away their publishing? Here are a few good reasons:
1) You need a monthly draw. In the beginning of my career, I needed a monthly income to support my family. I traded my publishing for that monthly check. Looking back, it was the right choice. It got my foot in the door. I had an amazing mentor/publisher. And I got some cuts. I came out close to even on a 5 year deal that I considered “Songwriting School”. I learned the craft and I learned how the business worked. That was invaluable.
2) You need someone to pitch your songs and do your admin. If this is ALL you need, you could probably get a co-pub deal in which you retain part of your publishing and sign another part (usually 1/2) away. That is not a bad deal unless you can do all of that on your own. Most of us cannot.
3) You trade it for a cut. There have been instances I have known of where an artist or record label asked for a share of the publishing in exchange for a cut. Depending on how much they ask for, this can be a good or bad deal. And, it can be a slippery slope. Once you do this one time, words gets around and you will get the same requests over and over. In rare instances, it’s probably a really good idea to give a little to get a lot. Just make sure that you are getting at least as much as you are getting back.
4) You trade it for a a great working relationship. If you can find a great publisher that will mentor you, then you are wise to trade some (or sometimes even all) of your publishing for a great situation in which you can learn and grow as a writer. There are also cases where an artist will sign writers. If you can sign with an artist that loves your work and will cut lots of your songs, then it’s probably a no-brainer.
In every case, you need to weigh your options and make an educated guess. You want to do your best to make sure the trade is either in your favor or an equal trade. But, don’t view signing away your publishing as an “evil” that must be endured. In the right situation, it can be the best thing you ever did!
Write on! Marty Dodson
Write Better Songs Faster
Songwriting Success is Clay & Marty's 10-day video series that will help you level-up your songs and finish them faster. Enter your email address to get started!